A payroll service pays your people and files your payroll taxes. A PEO does that and also becomes your co-employer for benefits, workers’ comp and HR compliance. Here is how they differ in liability, cost and tax credits.
Get a Free Credit Review
Tell us about your business and a specialist from our partner network will follow up.
"*" indicates required fields
The difference between a PEO and a payroll service is who the employer is. A payroll service works for you: it runs payroll and files taxes under your EIN, and you stay the only employer. A PEO enters a co-employment arrangement: it pays wages and files payroll taxes under its own EIN, sponsors benefits and usually workers’ comp, and shares HR compliance duties, while you still direct the work. A payroll service costs less. A PEO costs more but adds large-group benefits and, if it is IRS-certified, takes on federal employment tax liability for the wages it pays. See the best PEO companies for small business for a provider comparison.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Payroll service | PEO | |
|---|---|---|
| Employer of record | You | PEO and you (co-employment) |
| EIN on Form 941 | Yours | The PEO’s (aggregate return with Schedule R) |
| W-2 issued by | You (prepared by provider) | The PEO |
| Federal employment tax liability | You remain responsible | CPEO generally solely liable for wages it pays to worksite employees; non-certified PEO depends on the arrangement |
| Health benefits | You buy your own plan | PEO’s large-group plans |
| Workers’ comp | Your own policy | Usually under the PEO’s master policy |
| HR support | Limited or add-on | Included: handbooks, compliance, HR advisors |
| Typical cost | Low per-employee fee plus base fee | About $40 to $160 per employee per month, or 2% to 12% of payroll |
| Leaving | Switch software | Contract termination, benefits change, new state accounts |
Liability: The Difference Most Owners Miss
The IRS says a business that outsources payroll “generally remains responsible for paying taxes and filing returns.” If a payroll company fails to deposit your taxes, the IRS can still collect them from you. A certified PEO (CPEO) is different. Under IRC §3511, a CPEO is treated as the employer, and no other person is treated as the employer, for federal employment taxes on wages it pays to worksite employees. The IRS describes the CPEO as generally solely liable for those taxes. That protection applies only to certified PEOs, which is why we recommend checking the IRS list. Read more in what is a certified PEO.
When a Payroll Service Is Enough
- You have a handful of employees and no plans to offer health insurance.
- You already have a good small-group health plan and a broker you like.
- You have someone in-house who handles HR policies and compliance.
- You want the lowest monthly cost and full control of your own tax accounts.
A payroll service also keeps your own tax accounts and rate history intact. If you have a low state unemployment rate earned over years, that can be worth more than you might expect, and keeping it is simpler when you stay the sole employer.
Our guide to payroll tax compliance software covers what to look for in a payroll provider.
When a PEO Makes More Sense
- You are competing for hires against larger companies with better benefits.
- You have employees in several states and don’t want to manage each state’s rules.
- Workers’ comp is expensive or hard to place for your industry.
- No one on your team owns HR compliance, and handbooks, leave and terminations feel risky.
NAPEO’s 2025 client study found that 85% of PEO clients have fewer than 50 employees, so a PEO is not just for mid-size companies. A breakdown of fees is in our PEO cost guide.
Tax Credits Under Each Model
With a payroll service, you are the employer, so credits work the usual way: you screen for WOTC, claim it on Form 5884, and if you elect the R&D payroll offset, your provider attaches Form 8974 to your own Form 941.
With a CPEO, IRC §3511(d) keeps the research credit, WOTC, the small employer health insurance credit and several others with you, the customer. The CPEO counts the wages but must give you the data, and for the R&D payroll offset it attaches a Form 8974 for you to its aggregate Form 941 with Schedule R. Details are in PEOs and tax credits and the R&D payroll tax credit guide, and the R&D tax credit calculator gives a quick estimate.
What Changes When You Move to a PEO
- Tax accounts. Payroll taxes are reported under the PEO’s EIN. Your own federal and state accounts may go dormant, and the PEO may report state unemployment under its own rate.
- Pay stubs and W-2s. Employees see the PEO’s name as the employer on W-2s for wages it paid.
- Benefits. Employees enroll in the PEO’s plans, which may change networks, deductibles and plan years.
- Workers’ comp. Coverage usually moves to the PEO’s master policy.
- Day-to-day work. Nothing changes in who hires, sets pay, schedules and manages employees. That stays with you.
If you switch mid-year, ask how the PEO carries over year-to-date wages for the Social Security and FUTA wage bases. Federal law treats a certified PEO as a successor employer for wage base purposes, but state unemployment rules vary, and getting this wrong can mean paying some taxes twice.
Plan the communication too. Employees will get new benefit cards, a new portal and, for the year of the switch, possibly two W-2s: one from you for wages before the move and one from the PEO after it.
Questions to Decide
- What will health benefits cost per employee under each option for the same plan?
- What is our current workers’ comp and SUTA rate versus the PEO’s?
- Is the PEO on the IRS CPEO list under the entity named in the contract?
- How will WOTC screening and Form 8974 filings work?
- What does it take to leave in a year if it doesn’t work out?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a PEO the same as a payroll company?
No. A payroll company processes payroll under your EIN. A PEO becomes a co-employer, pays wages under its own EIN and adds benefits, workers’ comp and HR support.
Is a PEO more expensive than payroll?
Yes, in fees. Payroll services usually charge a small per-employee fee, while PEO admin fees run about $40 to $160 per employee per month. Benefit savings can offset part of the difference.
Who is liable for payroll taxes with a PEO?
With an IRS-certified PEO, the CPEO is generally solely liable for federal employment taxes on wages it pays to worksite employees. With a non-certified PEO or a payroll service, the business generally remains responsible.
Can I switch from a PEO back to a payroll service?
Yes. Plan for the contract notice period, new state tax accounts under your EIN, replacement benefits and year-end W-2 handling.
Does a PEO file my W-2s?
Yes. Because the PEO pays wages under its own EIN, it issues W-2s to worksite employees.
See what your business qualifies for. One free review covers cost segregation, R&D, hiring credits and benefits savings together. Call 360-641-7709 or use the button below.
Last updated November 2, 2026. This page is general information, not tax or legal advice. Confirm your situation with a qualified tax professional.